Cookies For All Occasions. A white plate holding five decorated cookies with drizzled white and dark chocolate, placed in front of a pink box of individually wrapped cookies on a pink satin fabric.

Made With Ingredients You Can Pronounce

Who
we are

We’re the Better Butter Cookie Company, based in Cookeville, TN—baking cookies that taste like home. Our recipes are rooted in grandma’s kitchen, made with pure butter, ingredients you can pronounce, and never any dyes. Every cookie is crafted with the warmth of the 1950s, when treats were simple, wholesome, and unforgettable.

We don’t just sell cookies—we tell a story. A story of faith, family, and flavor. As a Torah keeper, I honor the Sabbath and rest from Friday sunset to Saturday sunset, letting every part of this business reflect obedience and tradition.

And then there’s the Cookie Camper—our restored vintage camper that rolls up to weddings, markets, and community events, bringing cookies and nostalgia wherever it parks.

Better Butter isn’t just dessert. It’s a reminder of the way things used to be—cookies made with love, faith, and flavor that lasts.

Follow us on social